Twice in the last 40 years I have met intelligent ten year old children who had somehow never been told in so many words that television cartoons, movies, etc, were not real. One I only found out about because during a visit I had put on a video that included a show about special effects in movies, including two movies she and her younger brother had seen. (The Empire Strikes Back, and an Indiana Jones movie) Afterward she asked her father and apparently he said that "some things were exaggerated." She asked me what part of "Thundercats" was exaggerated. I had a little trouble getting it across to her that every single part of it was not true - the bipedal, English-speaking cats with magic powers, the space ships, the villains, everything. Mind you, this girl had acted in a school play based on "Ghostbusters", yet she had still believed that the movie of it was real.
Now I'm wondering just how common this is. It's insidious - I know at least one intelligent adult with a science career who admitted that when watching Star Trek as a young adult he had unconsciously assumed that the starscapes shown on the viewscreens were done by going up in a space ship and taking moving pictures, even though he knew that the plots were fiction.
What do you think:
At what age do most children realize that the characters they see in cartoons are not real, that the stories are not literally documentaries? Is there an age at which they figure it out for themselves? Or do they have to be told?
I don't remember what happened in my own case; I know my family complained once that certain movies frightened me when I was about five or six, but I don't remember it. I have to assume that I was told before I was ten, because I remember knowing that it was just a story at that age.
Now I'm wondering just how common this is. It's insidious - I know at least one intelligent adult with a science career who admitted that when watching Star Trek as a young adult he had unconsciously assumed that the starscapes shown on the viewscreens were done by going up in a space ship and taking moving pictures, even though he knew that the plots were fiction.
What do you think:
At what age do most children realize that the characters they see in cartoons are not real, that the stories are not literally documentaries? Is there an age at which they figure it out for themselves? Or do they have to be told?
I don't remember what happened in my own case; I know my family complained once that certain movies frightened me when I was about five or six, but I don't remember it. I have to assume that I was told before I was ten, because I remember knowing that it was just a story at that age.